PA Preferred Spotlight: Pure Joy Creamery

Kelsey Pantuck’s entrepreneurial spirit, agricultural roots and passion for local food systems all came together when she founded Pure Joy Creamery. This PA Preferred® small-batch yogurt business in Montgomery County provides the community with all-natural yogurt made with fresh ingredients sourced from local farmers and producers. 

Kelsey Pantuck of Pure Joy Creamery.

Pantuck joined PA Preferred in 2026. She says, “I like being PA Preferred because it helps customers know that the products they are buying truly support local PA agriculture. I think PA Preferred does great work supporting and promoting producers who work hard to create healthy and sustainable food products in their communities.” 

The Pure Joy Creamery products include four flavored yogurts  – plain, maple, vanilla and coffee vanilla – as well as rotating seasonal favorites and grab-and-go yogurt parfaits topped with granola or fruit jam. Pantuck partners with PA Preferred Maplehofe Dairy for milk and Whiskey Hollow Maple for maple syrup, keeping the production loop fresh and local.

Pure Joy Creamery yogurts.

Pantuck says, “I love running a small business because it is a creative outlet for me. Not only do I enjoy making a healthy and sustainable product, but I love connecting consumers to where their food comes from. I also love coming up with new flavor ideas and fun specials.” She shares her recipe experimentations, like fro-yo fudge pops, autumn spice yogurt and “tiramisu” chia pudding, on the Pure Joy Creamery Facebook and Instagram pages. 

Yogurt by Pure Joy Creamery.

So far, the most popular products are the vanilla and coffee vanilla yogurts. Pantuck says, “People love that the yogurt has a medium-level sweetness. The tangy, tart flavor of the yogurt still comes through, but it is balanced with cane sugar and pure vanilla extract and a subtle coffee flavor.” 

Montgomery County’s robust farm-to-table culture and over 500 working farms makes it a wonderful place for a venture like Pantuck’s creamery. “Pennsylvania is so rich in agriculture,” she says. “I love living and producing here. I make yogurt using whole milk from a local farm and nearly all the other ingredients I need can be purchased from local producers. I also feel that the community at large loves connecting with farmers and small businesses owners, which makes it a special place!”

Pure Joy Creamery yogurt parfaits.

You can find Pure Joy Creamery’s yogurt and parfait products at cafes and markets in southeastern Pennsylvania. 301 N. Lewis Rd., Royersford; (484) 369-9408.

This series was created in collaboration with PA Preferred. 

PA Preferred Logo Filled

PA Preferred® is Pennsylvania’s statewide branding program that promotes locally grown and processed food and other agricultural products.

Meet more PA Preferred farms and businesses...
Here!
  • Photos: Pure Joy Creamery